City Guide

Best Italian Restaurants in New York

By HypedAbout · 15 places · New York

15 Italian restaurants in New York that creators actually filmed, ranked by how many of them went.

1. 1
   

   Lucali

   Italian · Carroll Gardens · $$ Loved it

   • Calzone Mark, everything's amazing. Calzone is finally here. Small calzone, $19.

   American Turk · Jul 2025
2. 2
   

   Una Pizza Napoletana

   Italian · Lower East Side · $$$ Loved it

   • Roasted Pepper Appetizer It was so good. I wish I got burrata so I can mix it with it. It would have been perfect. Eight out of 10. Thank you so much. Hot pepper.
   • Taylor Cola It's really good. The anchovies are so good. It goes perfect with the pizza.

   American Turk · Jun 2025
3. 3
   

   Don Angie

   Italian · West Village · $$$ Loved it

   American Turk · Aug 2025
4. 4
   

   Ceres

   Italian · Little Italy · $$$$ Loved it

   YYZREVIEW · 🍕 Ceres Pizza – A New York City HOT SPOT! 🍕🇺🇸 · Oct 2026
5. 5
   

   Prince Street Pizza

   Italian · Nolita · $$ Loved it

   • Pepperoni Pizza That is very good, and I'm going to show you the undercarriage here because perfect amount of olive oil and perfect amount of crispiness.

   Tim Lee · New York's Legendary Pizza - $1 Slice Vs New York's #1 Rated Pizza · Mar 2026
6. 6
   

   Cipriani

   Italian · SoHo · $$$$ Liked it

   • Risotto Alla Primavera Now, that was a nice-looking risotto dish, and I... To put it simply, that risotto was lovely.

   James Andrews · Eating at Cipriani Downtown. PRETENTIOUS Celebrity Hot Spot? · Dec 2025
7. 7
   

   Torrisi

   Italian · Nolita · $$$$

   The VIP List · The real tea on Torrisi Miami #nyc #miami · Mar 2026
8. 8
   

   Via Carota

   Italian · West Village · $$$ Loved it

   • Calamari Wasn't too chewy. Not too chewy. And had a good crunch. Good batter. And definitely not frozen.
   • Straccetti Comparing this to other Italian restaurants, especially Michelin, I would say it's a 7.8.

   American Turk · Aug 2025
9. 9
   

   Rezdora

   Italian · Flatiron District · $$$$

   jamie lee 현주 · nyc vlog | holiday markets, trendy restaurants, hot chocolate, central park, brooklyn spots · Dec 2025
10. 10
    

    G&R Deli

    Italian · Indian Village · $ Liked it

    • Italian Ice Cream Cone (Meatball Sandwich) That tomato sauce is so tangy but sweet, and you've got that meatball, perfectly soft, fatty.

    Eating With Tod · Most viral sandwiches in NYC #nyc #newyork #foodie #sandwiches · Jul 2025
11. 11
    

    Chrissy's Pizza

    Italian · Greenpoint · $$ Loved it

    • Spicy White Pizza with Pepperoni It's so good. Oh my god.

    Vic and Jeff · NYC vlog - Eating like locals through Brooklyn and Queens (10 spots) · Mar 2026
12. 12
    

    Bar Pitti

    Italian · South Village · $$ Liked it

    American Turk · Feb 2025
13. 13
    

    Luigi's Pizza

    Italian · South Slope · $ Mixed

    UA Eats · One of Portnoy's Favorites! Is LUIGI's in Brooklyn Worth the Hype? · Aug 2025
14. 14
    

    Bad Roman

    Italian · Midtown Manhattan · $$$

    Joe Parys Eats · Everything I Ate At Bad Roman in New York City! 🍖🍰 #Shorts · Sep 2025
15. 15
    

    Di Fara Pizza

    Italian · Midwood · $$ Loved it

    UA Eats · Di Fara Pizza is WORTH THE HYPE! Trying Brooklyn's Iconic Pizza Spot · Dec 2024

Every place here is on the map because a food creator went and filmed it. About HypedAbout · All creator maps