City Guide

Best American Restaurants in New York

By HypedAbout · 15 places · New York

15 American restaurants in New York that creators actually filmed, ranked by how many of them went.

1. 1
   

   Peter Luger Steakhouse

   American · Southside · $$$$ Loved it

   • Porterhouse Steak For Two It just melts in your mouth like butter, siron over here. Medium rare.
   • Strudel The bottom of the pino dough has a crème brûlée flavor to it. Sweet and smoky like a marshmallow flavor. 9 out of 10.

   American Turk · POV: Solo Upscale Dinner at the Best Steakhouse in New York · Dec 2025
2. 2
   

   Hamburger America

   American · SoHo · $$ Mixed

   • Mott Burger That is a fantastic burger. I'm trying to put my finger on every aspect of it.

   Gary Eats · I Review The Best Burger in America! (I Travelled 4000 Miles) · Oct 2026
3. 3
   

   Mama's TOO

   American · West Village · $$

   JRS FAMILY VLOGS · WE FOUND NYC'S HIDDEN PIZZA GEM! Mama's Too! · Oct 2026
4. 4
   

   Golden Steer

   American · Greenwich Village · $$$$ Liked it

   • Roasted Brussels Sprouts Alongside my steak, I was enjoying a side of the roasted brussels sprouts, which contained honeycrisp apples, and now, that was a delicious side dish.
   • Black and White Cheesecake The cheesecake had a good look to it, and now, that was a good cheesecake.

   James Andrews · Eating at The Golden Steer. A LEGENDARY Vegas Steakhouse now in NYC · Feb 2026
5. 5
   

   Per Se

   American · Midtown Manhattan · $$$$ Loved it

   American Turk · Aug 2025
6. 6
   

   Eleven Madison Park

   American · Flatiron District · $$$$

   Food With Jerry · Eleven Madison Park vs Jungsik - Which NYC 3 Michelin Star Restaurant is Better? · Aug 2026
7. 7
   

   Golden Diner

   American · Two Bridges · $$

   Alan Barr · Trying New York’s most famous pancakes?! Worth a 4 hr wait?? · Sep 2026
8. 8
   

   The Modern

   American · Midtown West · $$$$

   Food With Jerry · Everything I Ate for NYC Restaurant Week 2026 · Aug 2026
9. 9
   

   The Chef's Table at Brooklyn Fare

   American · Hell's Kitchen · $$$$ Loved it

   • Maine diver scallop with vin jaune sauce One dish we never wanted to end?

   Anders & Kaitlin · 2 Michelin star restaurant hidden inside a grocery store in NY 🇺🇸 Chef’s Table at Brooklyn Fare ⭐️ · Oct 2025
10. 10
    

    Crown Shy

    American · Financial District · $$$$ Loved it

    • Potato Flatbread with Short Ribs Flatbread stuffed with short ribs topped. That was a good bite. Very flavorful.
    • Chicken Kofta with Rice Nine. I'd give it a nine, as well.

    American Turk · Oct 2025
11. 11
    

    Red Hook Tavern

    American · Red Hook · $$

    Jeremy Jacobowitz · Is Red Hook Tavern the Best Burger in NYC? · Aug 2026
12. 12
    

    Balthazar

    American · SoHo · $$$ Loved it

    • Steak Frites Now, that's good. Got perfect good cut.

    American Turk · Dec 2025
13. 13
    

    The Corner Store

    American · SoHo · $$$$ Loved it

    UA Eats · My Top 5 Eats of 2025! · Jan 2026
14. 14
    

    Danny & Coop's

    American · Ukrainian Village · $$ Loved it

    • Cheese Steak The steak was thin and moist and the Cooper Sharp cheese clung to the meat perfectly. I loved the sesame seed bread.

    James Andrews · Bradley Cooper’s Cheesesteak Restaurant · Dec 2025
15. 15
    

    Legasea Bar and Grill

    American · Garment District · $$ Liked it

    UA Eats · GREAT Steak on a BUDGET! 5 BEST NYC Steaks Under $40! · May 2025

Every place here is on the map because a food creator went and filmed it. About HypedAbout · All creator maps